The Great Escape

Written By Gaz

It may be a classic but can it live up to history? In this episode Gaz and Mel take on one of Hollywood’s classic war movies, The Great Escape (1963). How does it compare to the true story? How difficult was it directing Steve McQueen? We also discuss the true military experiences of Donald Pleasence, James Garner, Richard Attenborough, and Hannes Messemer.

Directed by the legendary John Sturges and starring Steve McQueen as Virgil Hilts in the role that would make him a Hollywood icon.

Real Movies Fake History is hosted by two friends, Gaz (the film nerd) and Mel (the history expert), who each episode discuss, debate and laugh about the real history behind diverse and important cinema.

We seek to discover the true story behind films apparently based on a true story. With a particular interest in gender and cultural representation, we love nothing more than to speak on how a particular film represents the world around us.

Join us as we talk about movies, history, and the truth in between. New episodes launch every month.

Featured
The Marvels review – An indicator of obvious decline
The Marvels review – An indicator of obvious decline

As sign-posted by the unfairly maligned girl-power scene in Avengers: Endgame, having three female leads in a $270 million dollar blockbuster is a step in the right direction, if a lately plotted one. It’s a shame the enormous and over-compensated human machinery of the Marvel Studios empire have simply fumbled the task of placing them in a story that illustrates their talents. As we watch the effective charisma of each performer fly across the screen, we’re assaulted with an abundance of dull, gentrified storytelling from a studio suffering from it’s own success.

Saltburn review
Saltburn review

You’re acceptance of Saltburn’s entertainment is connected to your willingness to spend time with unlikable characters. Our outsider is Oliver Quick (Barry Keoghan), a scouser Oxford undergraduate who’s lost amongst the university’s upper-class privilege. He struggles to fit in. He gets the worst seat in the dining hall. He isn’t invited to the Christmas party.

The Zone of Interest review
The Zone of Interest review

Jonathan Glazer’s disciplined The Zone of Interest (2023) is both a treatise on peripheral horror and an audacious act of demythologising. In the foreground, he adopts the slow living of upper-echelon Nazi life with it’s cups of tea and washing of long leather boots. In the background, the appalling questions raise their dreadful heads to turn domestic drama into appalling horror.

Napoleon review – Chunky and Grumpy
Napoleon review – Chunky and Grumpy

Napoleon huffs and puffs his way through the French emperor’s greatest hits, spinning a bleak and darkly colored yarn heavy on scale but light on personal revelations.

The Killer review – Brutal, cold and oddly simple, but is it good?
The Killer review – Brutal, cold and oddly simple, but is it good?

I’ve heard that Fincher splits his work into two categories, movies and films. Se7en (1995) is a movie, an audience pleasing thriller with conventional crime table-setting. Not low-brow exactly, but greasy and gruesome in its traditional mystery scares. But The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (2008) is a ‘film’, because thematically it’s a serious, unconventional, head-scratching experience full of thinly veiled philosophizing on the nature of life and death.

The Exorcist: Believer review - awful in the most obvious way
The Exorcist: Believer review - awful in the most obvious way

With the atrocious The Exorcist: Believer in theaters, David Gordon Green has reminded us of something that has been clear for decades: William Friedkin’s The Exorcist is not a franchise-able horror property. And the reason is because The Exorcist (1973) isn’t a horror movie, it’s a mystery.

Killers of a Flower Moon Review – A flawed adaptation
Killers of a Flower Moon Review – A flawed adaptation

Scorsese uses David Grann’s bestseller about the true 1920s murders as a guide to paint a wide canvas that provides us a fascinating exploration of a tragic story but also leaves us more exhausted than exhilarated.

The Creator review
The Creator review

Balancing big-budget world building, grief, and familial themes, Gareth Edwards’ ambitious sci-fi is primarily an action movie built from the bones of other, more original stories. And yet Edwards’ remarkable visual sensibility and a sense of gleeful homage keep this exciting endeavour mostly on track.

House of Gucci review - Gaga Cinema
House of Gucci review - Gaga Cinema

Ridley Scott’s House of Gucci is a pulpy amalgamation of The Godfather and The Bold and Beautiful. As equally serious as it is campy, it’s a family saga of corruption and back-stabbing that ultimately entertains because it may be the longest and most expensive soap opera ever produced.

The Matrix Resurrections review – Meta-textual Boredom
The Matrix Resurrections review – Meta-textual Boredom

Unfortunately The Matrix Resurrections is another reminder that this series has only ever had enough strong narrative ideas for a single entry. While Lana Wachowski provides some throwback moments for fans of the original 1999 release, what is incredible is how dated the execution feels.

Gaz
Previous

Quills